Theola Kilgore – “The Love of My Man”

Theola Kilgore blended gospel roots with soulful storytelling. Her voice carried deep emotion, whether she sang in church or on stage. Though her time in the spotlight was brief, her music made a lasting impact.

She is best remembered for her 1963 hit, “The Love of My Man.” But her career stretched beyond that one song. Kilgore recorded powerful music, influenced future singers, and helped shape soul music during its formative years.

Artist Profile: Theola Kilgore
Full Name Theola Kilgore
Born January 25, 1925 – Shreveport, Louisiana, USA
Died May 15, 2005 – Los Angeles, California, USA
Genres Gospel, Soul, R&B
Key Instruments Vocals
Notable Hits “The Love of My Man” (1963) – #21 Hot 100, #3 R&B
“This Is My Prayer” (1963) – #60 Hot 100
Record Labels Candix, Serock, Scepter, KT Records
Other Notable Tracks “Sound of My Man (Working on a Chain Gang)”
“It’s Gonna Be Alright”
“I Know That He Loves Me”
Legacy Influenced soul and gospel crossover artists
Revered in UK’s Northern Soul scene
Covered by Etta James and others

Early Life and Gospel Beginnings

Theola Kilgore was born on January 25, 1925, in Shreveport, Louisiana. Her family later moved to Oakland, California, where she spent most of her life.

She started singing in church as a child. Her powerful voice and deep emotion quickly stood out. By the 1950s, she became a popular gospel performer in the Bay Area. She joined the Mount Zion Spiritual Choir and appeared on their record Look to the Hills, where she was billed as “Theola Kilgord.”

Her church background shaped her singing style. You can hear the gospel influence in her phrasing, vocal power, and themes of hope and redemption.

Crossing Over to Secular Music

The transition from gospel to secular music was common in the 1950s and ’60s. Artists like Sam Cooke and Aretha Franklin followed this path. Theola Kilgore was no exception.

She caught the attention of Sam Cooke’s manager, J.W. Alexander. He introduced her to singer-songwriter and producer Ed Townsend. This connection changed the course of her career.

Her first secular single, The Sound of My Man (Working on a Chain Gang), was released on the Candix label in 1960. It was an answer record to Cooke’s hit Chain Gang. Cooke even co-wrote it. The song received modest attention and helped launch her secular career.

Major Hit: “The Love of My Man”

In 1963, Kilgore released The Love of My Man on Serock, a subsidiary of Scepter Records. Ed Townsend wrote the song, which was a secular reworking of the gospel track The Love of God, originally recorded by The Soul Stirrers.

Kilgore’s version preserved the spiritual tone while shifting to a romantic theme. Her soulful delivery and the song’s slow-burning arrangement struck a chord with audiences.

The single became a hit. It reached No. 21 on the Billboard Hot 100 and No. 3 on the R&B chart. It became her signature song.

The success earned her spots on national R&B tours and the “chitlin’ circuit,” a network of venues that showcased African American talent during segregation. She shared the stage with artists like Otis Redding, Jackie Wilson, and Etta James—who later covered The Love of My Man herself.

Follow-Up and Record Label

Later in 1963, Kilgore released This Is My Prayer, also written by Townsend. It charted at No. 60 on the Billboard pop chart. Though it wasn’t as big as her previous hit, it kept her name on the airwaves.

Encouraged by her success, Kilgore and Townsend launched their own label, KT Records. This gave her more control over her music, though her releases on KT didn’t achieve commercial success.

Songs like I Know That He Loves Me and I Don’t Care if I Never Get to Love You showcased her consistent vocal strength. But none matched the popularity of The Love of My Man.

“It’s Gonna Be Alright” and Northern Soul Fame

In later years, Kilgore released It’s Gonna Be Alright, a powerful and uplifting track. Though it didn’t chart in the U.S., it found a second life across the Atlantic.

British fans of Northern Soul—a movement that embraced lesser-known American soul records—discovered the song. It became a dancefloor favorite in UK clubs, where its driving rhythm and hopeful lyrics won over new generations of fans.

Final Years and Legacy

Theola Kilgore continued to perform and record into the 1970s. She never returned to the charts, but she remained respected in soul music circles.

She passed away on May 15, 2005, in Los Angeles, California, at the age of 80.

Though her discography was small, Kilgore’s work has stood the test of time. The Love of My Man remains a touchstone in soul music. Her blend of gospel passion and R&B heart paved the way for later artists to do the same.

Influence and Recognition

Kilgore’s work—especially The Love of My Man—has been covered by artists like Etta James, Bettye Swann, and others. Her heartfelt delivery inspired female soul singers who followed in her footsteps.

She remains a cherished voice among collectors of vintage soul and gospel music. Her early gospel recordings are sought after by enthusiasts, and her rare KT label singles fetch high prices among vinyl collectors.

Thanks to Northern Soul fans and reissue labels, many of her lesser-known tracks continue to be rediscovered by modern audiences.